Exam CISSP topic 1 question 402 discussion

I go with B

ChatGPT4.0 says: Conclusion While B (obtaining components from official sources over secured link) is a crucial step in ensuring the integrity and authenticity of the components, it does not fully address the broader risks associated with the use of third-party components. These components might still have inherent vulnerabilities or may not perform as expected. Therefore, D (implementing a process to verify the effectiveness of the software components and settings) remains the BEST method for comprehensively reducing the risk. This approach ensures that all components are thoroughly vetted for security, reliability, and compatibility, providing a higher level of assurance that the software will function as intended without introducing new vulnerabilities. Thus, I stand by the conclusion that D is the best overall method for reducing the risk associated with using readily available software components, even though B is also an important part of a robust security strategy.

While B ensures that components are acquired safely and likely from reputable sources, it does not provide assurance that the components themselves are free from vulnerabilities or fully effective.

I see people going to D. D is 'nice', but is quite time consuming, so it contradict the purpose of 'meet the project deadline !" B is simple to put in place, and it addresses the main risk which is downloading the packages from an untrusted source

It asks to reduce risk of utilizing third-party software, B is the best option for that

D. Implement a process to verify the effectiveness of the software components and settings. D. is a broader answer which includes B in it. So D. is a better answer choice to me than B.

using approved software development framework means already tested/reviewed...by manager

I go with D

I would suggest B. I think D is too narrow, we don't only want to take into account effectiveness, but mainly security.

A software security assessment involves analyzing the software components for vulnerabilities and other security weaknesses that could be exploited by attackers. The assessment should include a review of the software's code, configuration settings, and dependencies, as well as any known security issues or vulnerabilities. By conducting a software security assessment of the components, the developer can identify any security risks that may exist and take steps to address them before integrating the components into the web application. This can help to reduce the risk of security breaches, data loss, and other security incidents that could result from the use of insecure software components.

I go with B

Answer: D. Implement a process to verify the effectiveness of the software components and settings. Using readily available software components can be a time-saving practice for developers, but it also introduces certain risks, such as security vulnerabilities, compatibility issues, and license violations. To reduce the risk associated with this practice, it's essential to implement a process to verify the effectiveness of the software components and settings. Therefore, option D is the best method for reducing the risk associated with using readily available software components. This process should include reviewing the software components for known vulnerabilities, compatibility issues, and licensing restrictions. It should also include testing the components in the context of the web application to ensure that they work as expected and do not introduce any new vulnerabilities or issues.