Exam CBAP topic 1 question 467 discussion

D. Assess the impact on the business operations

D should be the answer.

Assess the impact on the business operations is correct. As per BABOK v3 8.3.4.3, business analysts review identified problems in order to assess the effect they may have on the operation of the organization or the ability of the solution to deliver its potential value. This requires determining the severity of the problem, the probability of the re-occurrence of the problem, the impact on the business operations, and the capacity of the business to absorb the impact.

BABOK v3 - 8.3.4.3 Impact assessment Business analysts review identified problems in order to assess the effect they may have on the operation of the organization or the ability of the solution to deliver its potential value. This requires determining the severity of the problem, the probability of the re-occurrence of the problem, the impact on the business operations, and the capacity of the business to absorb the impact. Business analysts identify which problems must be resolved, which can be mitigated through other activities or approaches, and which can be accepted.

Really C shouldn't be an answer as it's stated that this additional requirement will come in a future release. so , it's already part of the scope. Secondly, it's not clear the impact of the SLA breaching on the business operation. So based on the significancy of the issue , it should be the action either by reprioritize this requirement to come in an early release , or do nothing.

ABOK 8.3.4: Business analysts identify solution components which have dependencies on other solution components, and then determine if there is anything about those dependencies or other components that limit solution performance and value realization

Oh certainly, scope needs to be increased please.

If one scenario cannot met the SLA for a requirement which is already bound to a future release, then the scope should be increased. Answer C

The answer is C. . Increase the scope and include the dependent requirement

D - Assess Impact on business operations as per page 92 Impact analysis is performed to assess or evaluate the effect of a change. Traceability is a useful tool for performing impact analysis. When considering changes or additions to existing requirements, business analysts assess the impact of the proposed change by considering: • Benefit: the benefit that will be gained by accepting the change. • Cost: the total cost to implement the change including the cost to make the change, the cost of associated rework, and the opportunity costs such as the number of other features that may need to be sacrificed or deferred if the change is approved. • Impact: the number of customers or business processes affected if the change is accepted. • Schedule: the impact to the existing delivery commitments if the change is approved. • Urgency: the level of importance including the factors which drive necessity such as regulator or safety issues.

Babok Page-175 impact assessment-Assess Solution limitation Business analysts review identified problems in order to assess the effect they may have on the operation of the organization or the ability of the solution to deliver its potential value