Exam CIPP-E topic 1 question 11 discussion

B. That it takes the form of a Regulation as opposed to a Directive

Read the book please. The biggest problem of Directive is that it resulted in fragmented implementation of data protection across EU. The GDPR provides a uniform regulation. One-stop is just a feature.

B is correct. It takes the form of a Regulation rather than a Directive.

B for reasons stated by others

Option B: That it takes the form of a Regulation as opposed to a Directive is the correct answer. Regulation vs. Directive: A Regulation, like the GDPR, is directly applicable and enforceable in all EU member states without needing to be transposed into national law. This means that the GDPR provides a uniform set of rules that apply across the entire EU, ensuring consistency. In contrast, a Directive sets out goals that all EU countries must achieve, but it allows them to devise their own laws on how to reach these goals, which can lead to variations in implementation. Regards option A, One-Stop Shop Mechanism allows companies to deal with a single lead supervisory authority in the EU, simplifying regulatory oversight. While it aids in consistency, it is not as fundamental as the Regulation

B. That it takes the form of a Regulation as opposed to a Directive Regulations are directly applicable and enforceable in all EU member states without the need for national implementing legislation, ensuring a more uniform and consistent application of the law across the entire EU. In contrast, Directives require transposition into national law, which can lead to variations in implementation and enforcement.

Surely must be B as it affects all member states the same thus creating a level playing field

The answer is B. One of the "failures" of the Directive and Convention 108 was that it wasn't implemented consistently throughout the member states, but the GDPR being a Regulation allows synchronization on the approach to data protection.

Art. 37 GDPR states the conditions under which a DPO appointment is mandatory, thus, it isn't a blanket mandate, and D isn't the best answer.

Hi! This is my first time using this website. Are the answers given on the website the correct ones always?

I am confused between the answers - both A and B seem likely

A. That it essentially functions as a one-stop shop mechanism